Without spending a single centavo, the Bureau of Corrections (BuCor) earned a total of P142.72 million in 2016, representing a 45% share under its Joint Venture Agreement (JVA) with the Tagum Agricultural Development Co. Inc. (Tadeco).
Tadeco, the country’s biggest producer and exporter of Cavendish banana based in Davao del Norte, revealed the financial windfall for Bucor during a congressional hearing on the Tadeco-BuCor land deal.
At the instance of House of Representatives Speaker Pantaleon Alvarez, lawmakers are investigating alleged anomalies in the JVA that Alvarez said is illegal and disadvantageous to the government.
At the Department of Justice, Secretary Vitaliano Aguirre has spurned a request of Alvarez to cancel the JVA, saying that only President Rodrigo Duterte can declare the contract void.
On Monday, May 29, the Committee on Good Government and Public Accountability and the Committee on Justice conducted their second joint probe into the Tadeco-Bucor deal covering more than 5,000 hectares of the Davao Penal Colony (Dapecol) in Davao del Norte.
Tadeco president and CEO Alex Valoria informed the congressional committees that under the JVA BuCor was guaranteed a production share, which is a fixed amount, as well as a portion of the profits from the bananas exported by the company.
Both of these guaranteed earnings are reviewed and increased by 10 percent every five years, Valoria said.
Valoria said that on top of these financial benefits, Tadeco also pays BuCor for the farm training program and the stipend support of the inmates inside Dapecol (now the Davao Prison and Penal Farm), as part of the rehabilitation aspect of the JVA.
LEGAL AND ADVANTAGEOUS
“We have likewise made our position also clear. We are on solid constitutional grounds. Through the years, the JVA was proven to be undoubtedly advantageous to the government and BuCor,” Valoria told lawmakers in response to the comments made byAlvarez against the agreement.
Alvarez, who initiated the inquiry into the deal after figuring in a personal quarrel with Rep. Antonio Floirendo Jr., whose family owns Tadeco, attempted at the hearing to dispute Tadeco’s firm stand on the JVA and its inarguable benefits to the government.
THREAT OF PLUNDER
At one point during the hearing, Alvarez threatened filing of plunder charges against officials of the company, without any provocation from any of the resource persons or lawmakers present.
The Speaker reminded the Tadeco officials about Republic Act 7080 or the law penalizing the crime of plunder.
Alvarez said the company’s stockholders might “get involved.”
BONANZA
At the hearing, Valoria detailed the bonanza that went to BuCor under the JVA.
For 2016 alone, Valoria said Tadeco paid BuCor a guaranteed production share of P35.36 million, and a profit share of P9.53 million.
For the farm training program for inmates, Tadeco spent P5.5 million, and another P92.35 million for stipend support.
Thus, for 2016, Tadeco paid BuCor a total of P142,719,662, Valoria told lawmakers.
BuCor’s gain from the JVA does not include the taxes and fees paid to the government by Tadeco, which amounted to P438 million in 2016 alone, according to Valoria.
HYPOTHETICAL
When Alvarez asked how much of BuCor’s earnings from the JVA represented Tadeco’s gross income of about P1 billion in 2016, Valoria said “14.2 percent.”
Alvarez then asked Valoria if “hypothetically” an entity would agree to such a profit-sharing scheme of getting “only 14.2 percent.”
Valoria responded: “Hypothetically, Mr. Speaker, I would jump at it because I won’t have any risks. There is no single centavo involved.”
The Tadeco president explained that the P1 billion hypothetical estimate referred to the gross income of the company’s export business, and does not yet include the operational expenses and other costs incurred by the firm.
If the basis for BuCor’s percentage of the earnings were pegged on the net income, then BuCor’s share of P142.7 million would actually account for 45 percent of the P316 million net income attributable to the BuCor land covered by the JVA, according to Valoria.
Under the JVA, BuCor provides the land and manpower, while Tadeco invests on the capital in developing a portion of the Dapecol as a banana plantation primarily to help rehabilitate inmates inside the penal colony. Tadeco will assume all the business risks under the agreement.
Prior to today’s hearing, several local executives of Davao del Norte at the barangay and municipal levels have expressed their support to the Tadeco-BuCor JVA.
The local government officials of the province where Tadeco is based cited the benefits that the economy and the people of Mindanao receive from the JVA.
I just don’t understand how selfish and how inconsiderate these Mr. Speaker and his dog-like followers are. Why do they have to jeopardize the inmates,who’s trying to support their family in their own way, for their personal interest.
May ibang balak kasi si Alvarez na yan para sa TADECO. Ginagawa niyang busimess opportunity para kumita na naman ng malaki. Hindi na niya inisip kung ano ang magiging imahe niya bilang isang official ng gobyerno.
And Alvarez complains that its not enough. As if naman kasali siya sa usapan ng JVA ng BuCor at TADECO. Paandar niya lang yan para magkagulo ang gobyerno at taong bayan.
Sometimes, it feels like those inmates are living in a much more decent way than the corrupt government officials, they’re trying to work hard to support their loved ones. Does this Mr. Secretary knows the word responsibility? It seems like the inmates are smashing it in his face and yet he’s not aware of it! Such a shame!
Exactly. Something Aguirre and Alvarez has yet to achieve. Puro pandurugas at pandaraya ang paraan ng mga yan para lang makaraos sa mga gusto’t pangangailangan nila.
Hindi pa ba masaya ang gobyerno sa ganun? Walang puhunan pero lipak lipak ang tubo.
LikeLike
They want more. . . pagdating naman sa pera Hindi talga na kkontento ang corrupt. . .
LikeLike
Its a sickness. Kapag nasimulan, hindi na mapigilan. All they want is more and more. Akala naman nila ay madadala nila sa kanilang libingan.
LikeLike
I just don’t understand how selfish and how inconsiderate these Mr. Speaker and his dog-like followers are. Why do they have to jeopardize the inmates,who’s trying to support their family in their own way, for their personal interest.
LikeLike
it doesn’t matter if inmates lost thier job.. Hindi naman daw kase sila ung mawwalan.. they don’t care.. Ganyan sila ka selfish
LikeLike
May ibang balak kasi si Alvarez na yan para sa TADECO. Ginagawa niyang busimess opportunity para kumita na naman ng malaki. Hindi na niya inisip kung ano ang magiging imahe niya bilang isang official ng gobyerno.
LikeLike
Gawa yan inggit ni Alvarez kay Floirendo kaya nagkakaganyan siya. Gusto niya mapasaknya yung lupa.
LikeLike
Alam kase ni Mr. speaker na malaki ang potential.. e sobrang greedy nia kaya gusto nia sa kanya lang laht
LikeLike
Bigyan na lang sya ng libong lupa sa paso hahaha.. 😂😂 para tumigil na sya
LikeLike
Pati yung problema rin sa kabit niya kay madaam ni Floirendo. Kaysa ipagbati biya, maslalong pinalala ang problema kaya nadamay na ang buong bansa.
LikeLike
No single centavo spent by BuCor pero kumita ng milyon sa isang taon? Yan ba ang illegal Speaker?
LikeLike
Hindi na nila alam ung ibig sabihin ng illegal, pera na lang kase ung alam nila.
LikeLike
And Alvarez complains that its not enough. As if naman kasali siya sa usapan ng JVA ng BuCor at TADECO. Paandar niya lang yan para magkagulo ang gobyerno at taong bayan.
LikeLike
Sometimes, it feels like those inmates are living in a much more decent way than the corrupt government officials, they’re trying to work hard to support their loved ones. Does this Mr. Secretary knows the word responsibility? It seems like the inmates are smashing it in his face and yet he’s not aware of it! Such a shame!
LikeLike
He doesn’t know kaya hindi nia naggawa ung trabaho nia sa government.. Mas good example pa mga inmates dhil sila responsible sa ka nilang pamilya
LikeLike
Exactly. Something Aguirre and Alvarez has yet to achieve. Puro pandurugas at pandaraya ang paraan ng mga yan para lang makaraos sa mga gusto’t pangangailangan nila.
LikeLike